The Indianapolis Star Indiana All-Star team was announced on Tuesday. Below is the list of players along with the 12 players that Indiana Basketball Source voted onto the team. Trevor Andershock and Jeff Schoenle discussed the selection process player by player on the podcast.
| Actual Indiana All-Stars | Indiana Basketball Source All-Stars | |
| Desmond Bane | Desmond Bane | |
| Tucker Blackwell | Joey Brunk | |
| Joey Brunk | Marcus Burk | |
| Grant Gelon | Eron Gordon | |
| Eugene German | Kyle Guy | |
| Eron Gordon | Brachen Hazen | |
| Kyle Guy | Damien Jefferson | |
| Brachen Hazen | Kyle Mallers | |
| Damien Jefferson | Tremell Murphy | |
| Kyle Mallers | Dru Smith | |
| Tremell Murphy | CJ Walker | |
| Dru Smith | Jordan Walker | |
| CJ Walker |
**Notice, Indiana Basketball Source was only allowed to select 12 players while 13 players are on the team.